The Problem With One Big Number
Performance Max puts your ads on Search, Shopping, Display, YouTube, Gmail and Maps from a single campaign. Google decides how to split the budget. For years, you couldn't easily see that split, and that's where a lot of money quietly disappears.
The results can look great on paper. The question is whether they're coming from the places you think.
Sign 1: It's Taking Credit for Your Brand Searches
If someone searches for your business by name, they were probably going to find you anyway. Performance Max can show ads on those searches and count the sale or lead as its own.
How to check: look at the search terms insights for your PMax campaign. If your own brand name is one of the top categories, a big share of "results" may be customers you already had. Adding a brand exclusion list stops this.
Sign 2: Most of the Spend Is on Display and YouTube
For many service businesses, Display and YouTube produce cheap clicks and very few enquiries. If PMax is leaning heavily on them, your cost per lead can creep up while the campaign still looks busy.
How to check: open the Channel performance report for the campaign. It shows spend and conversions by channel. If Display is taking a large share of budget for a small share of conversions, that's money going in the wrong direction. Our guide to Performance Max channel controls explains the newer settings that let you limit this.
Sign 3: Leads Are Up but Sales Aren't
PMax is very good at finding whatever you tell it counts as a conversion. If that includes low-quality form fills, it will find lots of them, including spam.
How to check: compare PMax leads against what your team actually closed. If the numbers don't match, look at why fake and spam leads happen and tighten what counts as a conversion.
Sign 4: It's Cannibalising Your Search Campaigns
If you also run normal Search campaigns, PMax can compete with them for the same searches. You end up paying more for traffic you were already getting.
How to check: look at your Search campaign impressions and conversions before and after PMax launched. If they dropped as PMax grew, it may be taking over rather than adding new customers.
Sign 5: Your Product or Service Mix Is Lopsided
For ecommerce, PMax often pours budget into a handful of best-selling products and ignores the rest, even when other products have better margins.
How to check: look at the listing groups report. If a small number of products take most of the spend, consider splitting them into separate asset groups or campaigns so you control the budget.
Is PMax Ever Worth It?
Yes. For ecommerce businesses with a good product feed and accurate tracking, it can be one of the best-performing campaign types. It's also useful for reaching people earlier in the buying journey.
The problems start when it's left to run on its own with no brand exclusions, loose conversion goals and no one checking the channel split. That's when "great results" turn out to be existing customers and cheap Display clicks.
We review Performance Max for businesses across the North West, and our Manchester PPC team works with local ecommerce and lead-gen brands every day. If you want ongoing help, our PPC pricing is set out up front.
What to Do Next
If you want the full set-up picture, our Performance Max guide covers it from scratch.
